1. Texas A+ 12. Atlanta C+ 23. Syracuse C-
2. Helena A 13. Rochester C+ 24. Las Vegas C-
3. Cincinnati A 14. Austin C+ 25. Buffalo C-
4. Boise A 15. Colorado C+ 26. Chicago D+
5. Charlotte A- 16. Vancouver C+ 27. Fargo D
6. Kansas City B 17. Houston C 28. Memphis D-
7. Wichita B 18. Ottawa C 29. New Britain F
8. Pawtucket B- 19. Florida C 30. Hartford F
9. Monterrey B- 20. New York C- 31. Louisville F
10. Oakland B- 21. Tucson C- 32. San Francisco F
11. Chicago C+ 22. Pittsburgh C-
Top 5 Draft Picks: 1. Steve Ellenwood (TEX) 2. Eugene Eiland (BOI) 3. Angel Duran (CHA) 4. Trevor Ross (HEL) 5. Geoff McDade (HEL)
Top 5 Draft Misses: Calvin Suzuki 1-15 (MNT) 2.Tom Denny 1-4 (NY) 3.. Ronald Shaw 1-20 (CHI) 4. Wayne Beverlin 1-23 (SYR) 5. Kid Kimbrel 1-32 (FLA)
Top 5 Value Picks: 1. Chad Angelini 8-257 (MNT) 2. Dummy Duffy 7-240 (OTT) 3. Brad Grace 13-433 (VAN) 4. Wandy Blanco 12-382 (HEL) 5. William Aardsma 3-95 (KC)
AL NORTH
Fargo/Trenton-mannytanner
1st Rnd Picks (1-39) (4 Years ML Service Time)
Right off
the bat we see the first pick, he went unsigned though and this team would
draft 2nd next year. We will see how that worked out for them. 39,
50 and 83 did sign however and played sparingly in the majors. Greg Rizzuto
stole 20 bases in 127 games, Eugene Ramsey hit 3 homers in 101 AB’s. The 83rd
pick Robert O’Donnell was actually not too bad winning 12 games and saving 9 in
his short lived career (69 games)
Draft Grade: D, with the first pick going
unsigned it was always going to be an upward battle for a good grade. The 3
other players with Major League playing times did little to help as well.
Ottawa/Tacoma-Tomcecil 1st Rnd Picks (30) (12
Years ML Service Time)
With only 1
pick in the first round, and a late one at that (30) tomcecil was only able to
get a solid defender at 2nd/CF in Micah Amaya. Hit 11 homers and 66
RBI in his best season while also stealing 11 bases. At 79 in the draft we get
the bizarre Keith Kirkland, in ’43 pitched 19.2 innings allowing only 2 earned
runs. In his approximately 100 other innings gave up 67. Maybe my favourite
named player, Dummy Duffy was drafted at 240th in the 7th
round, he hit 61 career homers in 1138 AB’s including a single season best of
29.
Draft Grade: C, even Dummy Duffy can’t lift this draft
grade up past average.
Helena/Kansas City-olemiss33 1st Rnd Picks (12-35) (31 Years ML
Service Time)
Olemiss
made two very good picks in the first round, starting with the #12 Pick, Trevor Ross. He would win Gold Gloves in both
RF and LF and a Silver Slugger while playing CF. He would hit 386 homers and
steal 161 bases over his career with his best overall season being ’44 when he
hit 37 homers stole 20 bases while batting 282. At #35, Geoff McDade was
selected and is still pitching in the majors. Currently has 164 saves, with his
best being 40 in just his 2nd season. Has pitched 1205 games with an
ERA of 3.81. At 382nd Wandy Blanco was drafted and had one very good
season hitting 33 homers in just 413 AB’s. He would just hit 5 more in his next
season.
Draft Grade: A, Ross is a shade below a Hall of
Fame Player and to get a solid bullpen arm that has pitched over 1200 games at
35 is great haul. Excellent value considering the draft position. Two straight
A’s by the Helena franchise
Chicago/Detroit-Goldenboy00 1st Rnd Picks (27-43) (16 Years ML
Service Time)
At first
glance the #27 pick, MacBeth Murphy was not all that exciting…I mean I should
know I drafted him. But a deeper dive shows a solid career. Twice topped 20
homers and was usually good for double digit steals. Was sub-par in the field
however, when playing RF and 2nd his two primary positions. Happy Gabriel was drafted 43rd but never reached the majors. Kiki Bennet was taken 76th and despite
having a solid ERA (3.96) only got to play 55 games. GB got a couple other of
major league players, Flash Blanks a
catcher was taken 173rd and got into 279 games hitting 268 with 8
homers. The 589th pick Chip Reed pitched in 36 games and managed a
3.56 ERA but had little impact
Draft Grade: C+, the very definition of an average draft.
No stars but solid pieces.
AL EAST
Rochester/Toledo-z0601 1st Rnd Draft Picks (17) (16 Years ML Service Time)
The 17th
selection in the draft was the only player to make the majors for Rochester.
Bret Delmonico was about .500 for his career 177-172, throwing just 5 under
3000 Innings. He id strike out 2272 batters but had a very pedestrian ERA of
4.50.
Draft Grade: C+ , Delmonico was a solid SP for many years
but beyond that this draft was bleak
New York/Atlanta-rquin9 1st Rnd Draft Picks (4th) (15 Years ML Service Time)
Tom Denny
hung around for better then 15 season collecting 2073 hits but aside from a few
Okay seasons, was never really good. While a pretty good fielder 138+ plays at
3rd base, his best offensive season was in ’44 when he hit 10 homers
while batting .310 with a career high .800 OPS.
Draft Grade: C-, Denny is far below the type of
player you would hope to get at #4
Atlanta/Charlotte-JIMMYOF 1st Rnd Picks (22) (13 Years ML
Service Time)
With the 22nd
pick jimmy took workhorse SP Marcus Fontanez, he did finish with a sub 500
record 130-165 even though at the tail end of his career he had two strong
seasons back to back ’47-’48, when he went 36-17 over 430 innings with a 3.68
ERA.
Draft Grade: C+, Once again a team with only
one viable major league selection and while Marcus had seasons of borderline
stardom on the hole he was just an average Major leaguer.
Pawtucket-Shiffy 1st Rnd Picks (25) (19 Years ML
Service Time)
Wilking Candelario might be the player with least triples(12) to ever hit for the cycle.
The feat was accomplished in ’44, a
season in which he hit 1 triple and batted .227. Did hit 211 career homers including a career
high of 32 in ’45. Darby Rooney was a DITR drafted 299th overall. He
won 9 games twice in his career while pitching a combined 384 innings. Was a
less then stellar 33-52 for his career. Shiffy got a few seasons out of his 20th
round pick, Kurt Seitzer, a catcher who batted 210 over 251 games.
Draft Grade: B-, Candelario is pretty solid at #25 and a
couple of DITR who contributed some extra value.
AL SOUTH
Florida-Chunkym 1st Rnd Picks (32-46-49) (17 Years ML Service Time)
Chunky had
three 1st round draft picks with two making the majors, his 32nd
pick Kid Kimbrel was the one that did not. At 46th the big swinger Chad Gibson
was selected. He hit hover 30 homers in each of his first three seasons
including a career high of 41 in ’41. He also struck out 397 times in those
three years. Three picks later at 49
Gerald Niemann was taken and while he only hit 3 homers in his career hid did
steal 94 bases in 396 Games. At #113 Robel Nolan a sturdy catcher from South
Dakota got the call. His best, and really his only season of note was in ’44
when he hit 13 homers with 36 RBI while batting 300
Draft Grade: C, none of the 1st
round selections where all that high and none of them really panned out all
that well either. After two really strong drafts this was a step back for the
Florida franchise.
Austin/Littlerock-sylemark 1st Rnd Picks
(10) (14 Yeasrs ML Service Time)
Here is a
pick I am pretty familiar with, Billy Beltre was drafted 10th
overall and spent 5 of his better seasons as part of my Vancouver franchise. He
is still pitching effectively in the majors 10-10 in 172 innings so far. Has a
solid 143-156 record with a 3.98 ERA. By no means ever an ACE he is the type of
arm that most seasons you could slot in the 3/4 spot in almost any rotation.
Draft Grade: C+, Almost exactly what you expect
from a #10 pick
Monterrey-eric1214 1st Rnd Draft Picks (15) (14 Years ML Service Time)
Erics pick
in the 1st round, #15 Calvin Suzuki only played for three seasons
and had one good one going 6-0 with 2 saves and a 3.50 ERA. His career ERA was
almost 5.00 though. The disappointment
from that first round selection can be somewhat removed after a nice pick at
257th, Chad Angelini. He hit 128 career homers most over a 6 years
stretch where he averaged 15 homers a season.
Draft Grade: B-. Suzuki might be one of the
bigger misses in this draft, but Angelini seems to be one of the better
surprise picks. I will call this a slight win for eric
Memphis/Richmond-Wallyworld 1st Rnd Selections (2) (4 years Ml
Service Time)
Wally had
the 2nd selection overall and took Beamer Moseley, he went unsigned
and I think no contract was even tendered to him as no compensation pick was
given the following season so that is a huge miss fire. At 51 however wally
need get JD Weaver a plucky 2nd baseman that had marginal success in
the majors hitting 11 homers and stealing 19 bases as a rookie.
Draft Grade : D-, getting something in the 2nd
round is nice, but letting the first round pick, especially the 2nd
overall go without even making an offer is almost grounds for dismissal as a GM
AL WEST
Tucson/Los Angeles-ck22 1st Rnd Picks (26) (7 Years ML Service Time)
Ck22 was
only able to snag one major league player in this draft, Polin James. His best
season was his last in the majors when he went 15-12 while pitching almost 200
innings with a 4.72 ERA. Only won 53 the rest of his career with an ERA well
over 5
Draft Grade: C-. another rather disappointing draft for the
Tucson team, with only the one major leaguer who will be forgotten when I
finish this sentence
Oakland/Las Vegas-axtell 1st Rnd Picks (21) (22 Years ML Service Time)
At #21
Axtell got the long serving SP Ryan Byrd, He pitched almost 2700 innings in his
career making a very solid 445 starts. Finished almost 500 going 160-167 for
his career finishing with 2128 K’s. 70th overall was Lonny Ramirezwho got up to the majors for parts of two seasons and 1 full one that saw him
hit 15 homers and a 234 average. Much later at 423, relief pitcher Carl Hatcher
was selected. Never had a great season, his best was a very pedestrian 4-5 with
2 saves a 4.82 ERA
Draft Grade: B-, Getting a pitcher who can out almost
3000innings mid way thru the 1st round is pretty good. A little more
this and that helped out as well.
Wichita/Anaheim-nadawg77 1st Rnd Picks (19-42) (15 Years ML
Service Time)
With two
first round picks nadawg was able to get one major leaguer, Leonardo Bird. Charley Adams the 42nd pick went
unsigned. Bird was a multiple All Star
catcher who should honestly get a look at being in the Hall. 2350 career hits
with a 308 AVG. His best season was ’44
when he batted 359 with 18 homers and 84 RBI.
Draft Grade: B, Bird is a great pick at #19 but the fact that almost every other draft
pick went unsigned it makes it tough for the draft as a whole to be considered
a success.
Colorado/St. Louis-picc818 1st Rnd Picks (7) (11 Years ML Service Time)
Picc went
for a bullpen arm at #7 in the draft and selected Kes George. He saved 218
games in his career including 5 seasons with over 30. Made the all star team 3
times and won a Fire Man award once. His final ERA of 4.28 points to some rough
seasons in his career. In lucky round 13
picc got Everett Dent who pitched 80 innings in the bigs winning 6 games and
losing the same
Draft Grade: C+, George was decent pick but not really a #7
impact kind of guy. Still a huge upgrade over the D from last season
NL NORTH
Pittsburgh-verik22 1st Rnd Picks (44,48)
(15 Years ML Service Time)
Paxton Bush
was selected 44th and actually spent one season as a terrible
starter 5-13 with a 6.45 ERA and three fairly average seasons as a
reliever 13-7 2 saves with and ERA
around 4.50. 4 picks later was Wally Parrish, a Left fielder that hit more like a 2nd baseman. His best
season was in ’45 when he batter 305 with 19 homers. He finished with 107
homers and a 728 OPS. Verik got a few
seasons from his 13th round pick Kent Catricala, the stocky 2nd
baseman hit 11 homers in 493 AB’s while batting 241.
Draft Grade: C-, big step back for the
Pittsburgh franchise after grading A- and B+ in the last two drafts.
Buffalo/Columbus-ab90 1st Rnd Pick (33,47)
(12 Years ML Service Time)
Tomas James
was the only one of the two first rounders to enjoy anytime in the majors. Would
mostly work as a starter, three times topping 200 innings but only twice
winning over 10 games. He would finish his career 55-84 with a 4.87 ERA. At the
tail end of the 2nd round #82, Eswalin Gallardo was drafted and was
really a bad major league pitcher but did throw a No Hitter in his Rookie
season. I am assuming he won that start but would only win 8 more games in his
career.
Draft Grade: C-, the no-hitter from Gallardo is
nice but after that its weak draft result
Chicago/Burlington-xatomsmasher 1st Rnd Picks (20) (15
years ML Service Time)
Atomsmasher
got 15 years of service but only 6 came from his first round selection Ronald Shaw. Went 42-72 in his career including
his best season when he went 10-11 with
a solid 4.18 ERA. The giant Dude Jefferies (6’8) was drafted 101st overall. He would only win 7 games
in his career and would finish his career with an ERA over 6. Ham Eckstein
(422) and Walt Jacquez (486) also got a shot at the bigs and combined went
50-102 in 1200+ innings with and ERA of about 5.77
Draft Grade: D+, another team with a top 20
Pick that didn’t pan out…and neither did any of the other picks
New Britain-nosirrommij2 1st Rnd Picks (16,41) (0 Years ML
Service)
Draft
Grade: F None of the top 6 picks were
signed. Too not get a anything at all hurts, but considering that this team was
a just a few years away from 3 straight 100+ wins Nosirr must have been doing
something right.
NL EAST
Cincinnati/Hartford-goldgreen 1st Rnd Picks (13,28,36,38,40)
(74 Years ML Service Time)
This is
going to be a big one, Haywood Douglass whose career is starting to wrap up. He
has 171 wins against 142 losses and a 4.36 ERA. In his 17 year career his best
season was in ’45 when he went 15-2 with
a 3.24. At #28 possibly the best
fielding SS this world has ever seen was selected. Takuya Tuiasosopo was only a 217 career
hitter he did hit 257 homers with 7 seasons over 20. He had 288 + plays and won an incredible 9
Gold Gloves. With the 36th pick Heinie Tartamella who hit 385 homers
was taken. Spent some time in RF and LF
but was a great 1st baseman. Topped 40 homers 5 times including an
incredible season in ’43 when he hit 62 with 145 runs batted in. Two picks later, gold grabbed another Gold Glove
SS, Jeffrey Langfels. He would win 2 Gold Gloves while being a 226 hitter with
limited power (56 Homers) and speed (48 Steals). The last of the 1st round
selections was Relief pitcher Charlie McMasters, he would pitch for parts of 8
seasons appearing in 212 games winning 20 and saving 13 more. Gold struck just
that with his pick in the 2nd round Patsy Ramirez, a relief pitcher
who made the All-Star team once and would have 4 seasons in which he saved over
10 games. Last and probably least was
the 4th rounder Pedro James. He won 10 games and had 5 saves over
his 158 Game career.
Draft Grade: A, Gold rebounded with this draft after
slumping to a C- last season. Maybe no
Hall of Famers, but three very strong players and a second group of major
league talent
Syracuse-bdrose 1st Rnd Picks (23) (8 Years ML Service Time)
Bdrose only
had one selection that made any real impact and that was Wayne Beverlin, mostly
a starting pitcher, he went 42-65 in his career with a 5.03 ERA in just over
900 innings. Only once did he have an ERA under while pitching over 100
innings. Dick Stephens was drafted 72nd overall but never did much
aside from stealing 14 bases.
Draft Grade: C-. a little bit of value from
Beverlin but not what you need from a pick that high
Hartford/New York-Sonofodin52
1st Rnd Picks
(11) (0 Years of ML Service Time)
Draft Grade: F
First pick went unsigned and no body else made it to the majors. The 765th
pick Adys Guerra has somehow managed to keep playing minor league baseball. He
has pitched in 901 Minor league games but isn’t great down there either. This
franchise is one of the worst drafting teams to this date.
Kansas City/Scranton-pitboss13 1st Rnd Picks (14) (26 Years ML Service time)
The 14th
pick overall was Tom Eppley who in his Rookie season went 17-9 and in his last
season in the majors he went 13-4. In between all that he was pretty much a 500
pitcher going 165-162 pitching almost 3000 innings with a 4.19 ERA. Alex Bochtler #63 was decent for a couple of
seasons 8-8 in one and 10-13 in the next but his career was short lived and
over two years later. #95 William Aardsma
was a free swinging catcher who racked up 851 K’s in just 3700 AB’s. He
did mash 173 homers including a career high 32 in his first full season to go
with an 828 OPS
Draft Grade: B, solid drafting by pitboss getting a workhorse SP and a solid catcher
in the third round.
NL SOUTH
Charlotte/New Orleans-purplehaze54 1st Rnd Picks (5) (17 Years ML Service Time)
Angel Duran was drafted 5th overall and is a borderline hall of famer in my
humble opinion. A top flight defender at
2nd base he was also a great offensive player. 370 homers 218 steals
and over 2300 career hits. His best season was ’47 when he hit 36 homers with
121 RBI and 26 steals while batting a best 293. JO Miro who was the 54th
pick taken and played for parts of 5 seasons. While he did go 8-8 in his rookie
season he sported a 6.51 ERA that season and a 5.61 for his career.
Draft Grade: A-, you could argue that Duran is the best player
drafted. But after the draft was a disappointment
Texas/Durham-sbdmasters 1st Rnd Picks (3-9) (37 Years ML Service Time)
Is the #3
pick a Hall of Famer? Steve Ellenwood was a professional hitter from day one of
his major league career. Finishing with 2361 hits and an incredible 317 AVG. He
popped 311 homers and stole an amazing 520 bases. Multiple awards including an MVP in ’41 but
it could be argued that isn’t his best season.
With a 2nd early first round pick at #9 sbd grabbed a solid
catcher Ralph Hollins. He was a multiple all-star and had a strong if not
spectacular career with 226 Homers and a .296 AVG. At #52 a defense first SS was drafted. Sean Douglass excelled with the glove (82+ plays) but was less exciting at the
plate. A career 234 hitter he had his best season in ’40 when he hit 13 homers
with a 259 avg. The #85 pick was Andy Slaughter, great grand son of Enos. The
boy could draw a walk but was a pretty basic batter and his career was over
after 534 AB’s
Draft Grade: A+, love this draft. A hall of
famer?, An Allstar Catcher and a defensive SS.
Louisville-Mattster24 1st Rnd Picks None (0 Years ML
Service Time)
Draft Grade: F
Louisville has gone from a solid C to a D+ to an F. Not a positive trend
Houston/Nashville-Kingkai53 1st Rnd Picks (18,37)
(14 Years ML Service Time)
Only one of
kingkais picks made it to the majors for any length of time. Joey Luebbers the
#18 pick took a few seasons to get his act together. After that he was a pretty
solid 20+ homer guy for a few seasons, finishing with 258 round trippers while
also stealing 212 bases.
Draft Grade: C, Joey is a solid pick and this is there best
draft in three seasons.
NL WEST
Vancouver/Omaha-outlaw 6-4-3 1st Rnd Picks (31-45) (13 Years ML Service Time)
Miller Wisdom some how hung around for 5 seasons despite not being a very good
hitter. He was a solid defender while
playing 3rd but for his career was just a 224 hitter that hit 19
homers and stole 18 bases in 300+ games.
Dennis Bailey the 45th pick burst onto the scene in his
rookie season with a 827 OPS and 24 homers. Fell off a bit in his sophomore
season but still managed to hit 18 homers in 299 AB’s But after that never appeared in a major
league game again. Way down in the 13th round Brad Grace was drafted
and hung around for 6 seasons as a pretty decent bullpen arm. He finished with
a solid 24-11 record while appearing in 334 games.
Draft Grade: C+, this grade pretty much hinges
on one very good season from Bailey and a surprise career from Grace
Boise-Hawkeyeone 1st Rnd Draft Picks (6,29,34)
(24 Years ML Service Time)
#6 Eugene Eiland, did we not put this guy in the Hall yet? That’s stupid if we didn’t. Dynamic fielder
at 3rd and 2nd. All types of awards. 475 homers, 512
steals and a career OPS of 807. I don’t care what his average was, this guy was
baseball! At #29 Julio Soriano was
decent defender up the middle, and could steal a base, 115 while only being
caught 16 times. The last of the 1st rounders was #34 Javier James,
the starting pitcher twice won over ten games but also lost 18 one season while
getting shelled to the tune of a 6.26 ERA
Draft Grade: A, got a hall of famer at #6. Considering the
1st two picks of this seasons drafts went unsigned that is a huge
get
San Francisco/Portland-She said 1st Rnd Picks (8) (0 Years ML Service Time)
Draft Grade: F, the #8 pick went unsigned, its
looks like refusal as opposed to a lack of an offer. Even still no players
equals an F
Las Vegas/Vancouver-aaronbrown99 1st Rnd Picks (24) (7 Years ML Service Time)
Andrew Cox
was a 7 year pro who was pretty good in seasons that he wasn’t bad in. Threw 90
innings with a 2.98 ERA in his second season.
Finished his career with a respectable 3.43 and 1.28 WHIP in 352 Innings
Draft Grade: C-, Andrew would be nice as a 2nd
or 3rd player drafted by a team but as the first and only major league
player taken it’s a bit of a loss